According to the data, “66% of U.S. households, or we can say approximately 86.9 million families, own some kind of pet, and they spent around 136 billion on their pets and on pet supplies.” (Source). 

It's clearer than ever: choosing the right products matters. In this blog, we'll walk you through what you should look for from the best pet supply store in NYC.

Why Does Choosing the Right Pet Supplies Matter?

If you're like most NYC pet parents, your furry friend isn't just a pet—they're family. That's why choosing the right supplies from the best pet supply store in NYC goes beyond buying what's cheapest or most convenient. 

Good-quality food, toys, grooming items, and accessories all play a big role in your pet's overall health and happiness.

In a fast-paced city like New York, where space, noise, and air quality can affect your pet's well-being, the supplies you pick matter more than you might think. Poor-quality treats might upset your pet's stomach. 

A cheap leash might snap mid-walk. And bedding that doesn't support your dog or cat's joints can lead to long-term discomfort.

That's why when people search for the best pet supply store in NYC, they're not just looking for a shop; they're looking for trust, reliability, and products that truly meet their pet's needs. 

So let's move it further to know what to buy from the best pet supply stores in NYC.

Food & Treats—What to Look for and What to Avoid?

When it comes to feeding your pet, quality is everything. The right food supports healthy digestion, energy levels, shiny coats, and even behavior. 

But not all pet foods are created equal—and many NYC pet owners unknowingly fall into the trap of choosing based on price or packaging.

Here's what to look for when shopping for food and treats:

  • Real meat or fish is listed first on the ingredient label, as it ensures your pet gets a solid source of protein to support muscle strength and immune function.
  • Grain-free and limited-ingredient recipes, which can help pets with food sensitivities or allergies digest their meals more efficiently.
  • No artificial ingredients, colors, or flavors should be included in your pet's food, because natural ingredients are gentler on your pet's system and reduce the risk of unwanted reactions. 
  • Essential nutrients like vitamins, minerals, and omega fatty acids are necessary and contribute to a shiny coat, strong joints, and healthy skin.

And here are some things you need to avoid:

  • Meat by-products or vague terms like animal meat, which often mean lower-quality filler proteins.
  • Corn, wheat, and soy are primary ingredients, as they offer less nutritional value and can upset digestion. 
  • High sugar and salt levels in treats, which can lead to weight gain or health issues over time. 
  • Chemical preservatives and artificial additives, which can cause long-term health risks.

For those seeking the best supplies store in NYC, knowing what's in your pet's bowl is step one. Choosing clean, nutritious, and trustworthy products makes all the difference.

Grooming Essentials that Keeps Your Pet Healthy

Grooming isn't just about making your pet look cute—it's an important part of keeping them healthy, especially in a busy and sometimes dusty city like NYC.

Regular grooming helps prevent skin issues, keeps their coat clean and shiny, and even allows you to spot problems early, like irritation in skin, fleas, or dryness. 

If you're a new or seasoned pet parent, here are a few essential yet best pet grooming supplies from stores in NYC you should always have on hand:

  • A gentle, pet-safe shampoo is a must-have that is free from harsh chemicals and fragrances, which helps maintain healthy skin without causing irritation.
  • A quality brush or comb suited for your pet's coat type—long-haired pets need de-shedding tools, while short-haired pets benefit from soft bristle brushes. 
  • Pet-friendly wipes that are perfect for quick cleanups after walks, especially useful for wiping paws during rainy or snowy NYC days. 
  • Ear cleaning pads and pet-safe toothpaste, which help reduce the risk of infections and maintain good hygiene overall.

When you're looking for the best pet supplies to care for your pet properly, grooming tools are just as important as food or toys—they're part of a routine that keeps your pet happy, comfortable, and healthy.

Toys and Mental Enrichment—Keeping Pets Engaged Indoors

Living in NYC often means your pet spends a lot of time indoors. While that's cozy, it also means they can get bored easily. Boredom in pets can lead to destructive behavior, stress, or even weight gain. 

According to a research study, “It is found that food-based enrichment toys, such as puzzle feeders, lead to more natural feeding behaviors and lower stress levels for the pet dogs.” (Source).

That's where the right toys and enrichment tools come in—they help keep your furry friend mentally happy and physically active. 

Here are some great types of toys and enrichment products from the best pet supply stores in NYC you need to consider for your pet:

  • Interactive Puzzle Toys 

These toys challenge your pet to figure out how to get treats, providing both fun and mental exercise. These toys are durable and easy to clean as they are made with natural latex rubber. 

  • Squeaky or Textured Toys

These squeaky toys engage your pet's senses and provide a source of entertainment when you're not home. 

  • Durable Chew Toys

Chew toys, especially for puppies and dogs that like to nibble, help satisfy their natural urge to chew while protecting your furniture. 

  • Treat-Dispensing Balls or Feeders

These types of toys or feeders are a fun way for you and your pet to make them work a little for finding their meal. 

  • Cat Teaser Wands or Motion-Activated Toys

These toys keep felines active and alert—even in smaller living spaces. With this one toy, you can get your pets to run, jump, chase, and pounce. 

Including a variety of the best enrichment pet supplies in NYC in your pet's routine is one of the easiest ways to reduce anxiety, build confidence, and support their overall well-being—especially when access to outdoor space is limited.

Everyday Essentials You Might Overlook

When shopping for your pet, it's easy to focus on food, toys, and grooming—but sometimes, it's the everyday basics that make the biggest difference. 

Items like bowls, collars, leashes, and travel dispensers play a huge role in your pet's comfort and safety.

These essentials are used daily, so choosing the right ones from the best pet supply stores in NYC matters just as much as selecting the perfect food or treat.

Here are a few commonly overlooked essentials to keep an eye out for:

  • Non-slip stainless steel bowls, which are more hygienic and durable than plastic, and prevent spills during mealtime. 
  • Comfortable, adjustable collars or harnesses are padded and secure and especially important for active pets in NYC's busy streets.
  • High-quality leashes with strong clips and ergonomic handles that make daily walks safer for both the pet and the pet owner. 
  • Portable travel containers or dispensers are essential for food and water—ideal for weekend trips, vet visits, or park days.

When browsing the best pet supply store in NYC that pet owners trust, don't forget these basics. They're simple but essential for your pet's daily routine and overall well-being.

Wrapping Up

Being a pet parent in a bustling city like NYC comes with its own challenges—but with the best pet supplies, your pet can thrive just as much in a high-rise as in a backyard. 

From food and grooming to toys and daily basics, every product you choose plays a critical role in your pet's happiness and health. Most people searching for the best pet supplies store in NYC aren't just looking for shelves of products—they want ease, reliability, and a store that understands city pet life. 

Visit today 705 BRBR, which helps make pet care easier, faster, and more enjoyable. 

Treat your pet to the best—because they deserve nothing less.